It’s 11.PM at Barajas, Madrid, and on the impeccable flat screens dotted around the gargantuan halls and corridors of my terminal scrolls the information that the last flight to Lisbon has been delayed due to unforeseen yet oh-so-volatile-and-hopefully-temporary weather conditions. I vainly wish for snow, even in my warm country; that at least would be a dignified reason to delay a late flight on a Sunday evening.
Alas, the fury of the thunders and the rage of the winds must be reserved for those stratospheric layers where only eagles and Airbuses dare. Outside, I recall, it is actually quite warm for such a winter night in the middle of the Iberian Peninsula and I am left to wonder what could possible detain such a small flight.
Wandering around the deserted floors, I notice the airport stores are all closing for the day. Beefy security patrols perambulate the halls, darting nervous looks amongst the lone and stranded people who have cuddled against some rigid bench in resigned expectation of a sleepless night to come. I walk inside a small bookshop in search of a magazine and buy The Economist out of silent desperation.
On a stand, next to the counter, lies the Séccion International of publications, with its neat rows of cosmopolitan literature tightly packed into the only space books are allowed to occupy.
Expecting to draw some comedic satisfaction out of seeing several volumes of either the Da Vinci Code or The Secret translated into Spanish (which would probably only enhance the source material, in a very alarming and paradoxical kind of way), I approach the stand. I end up picking up a book called The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Hamid and move it over to the counter where a sleepy lady proceeds to register the purchase and slip the slim book into a slender red plastic bag. At this moment in time, I know nothing of the book except what the emphatic cover quotations dramatically inform me: that it made the shortlist for the 2007 Booker and that a bunch of journalists and writers love it. It takes me, in fact, a few weeks before I even start reading it back at home.
Set in today’s age and with the sum of today’s fears well at hand, the book is a first hand chronicle of how a bright Pakistani boy undergoes a formal education in America, thrives in NewYork, and returns to his home land following the events of 9/11 as a disenchanted and burdened Arab with a deepening identity crisis. Renouncing the western world, he electsto lead a quiet life in Lahore, teaching at a University and protecting his family from the impending war with his sovereign neighbours.
The most ingenious aspect of Hamid’s work is possibly the way the very title plays against us from the outset and – midway into the novel – forces the reader to embark on a particularly lucid and impartial evaluation of character. But only midway; for you see, a first person narrative by a Pakistani named Changez (let’s ignore for a moment how awkward and silly the name sounds) does in fact compel us to believe we are witnessing a grand tale of disillusion, disappointment, and perhaps even bloody revenge by this intelligent and well spoken Arab fellow spewing the contents of his personal life to a complete American stranger who incautiously wandered into an establishment in old Lahore. That he may not be this unwilling fundamentalist to which the title alludes is something which only becomes clear when it’s almost too late to invert our constructed views on these characters.
Changez’ past American life was spent in high-polished corporate environments, doing the deeds commonly associated with the most ruthless and impersonal manifestations of western globalisation. In so many words, his job was to appraise companies, most of them on the verge of financial collapse and eager to find an audited reason to perform some cut backs on their staff. In this corporate America, human tissue just happens to be the soft tissue, and Changez quickly realises he is actually appraising the dispensable organic parts of these tentacular and faceless entities rather than the perceived market value of a given firm.
A few trips abroad make the young hotshot realise that in fact, people can hate his guts simply because he is indisputably American, performs a typically American corporate job, dresses like an American CEO and hangs out in the company of Americans. American here means of course Western; one could easily replace Mr. Changez with Mr. Smith, Frau Fritz or Monsieur Bonhomme and nary a thing would change in terms of instintictive hatred.
Changez’ most natural reaction – when confronted with this unexpected display of rampant hatred – is quite obviously to hate the buggers back, starting with the unavoidable and expressive venomous stares. These initial loveless exchanges already represent a form of vicious fundamentalism, strong and irrational, and the novel’s protagonist finds their ethereal and contagious presence to be profoundly unsettling.
Though all the major components of an intelligent and provocative analysis are present, the novel never seems able to fully flesh them out. Hamid gathers an effective enough cast but forgets to bend and twist their shapes into something more plausible, if not palatable. Erica, the protagonist’s love interest, is deliciously constructed as the epitomal modern woman: beautiful, intelligent, ambitious, heavily medicated, and utterly psychotic. Unable to get over a teen love drama of her younger MTV years, she commits suicide in a mental institution and is never heard from again.
Sure, this drives the point home well enough. So do the patronising conversations between Changez and his immediate boss or his work colleagues, who don’t seem to have an ounce of interesting things to offer except the same brand og hollow and plastic diatribes that could have come out a legal drama sitcom – and not even a particularly good one. It’s a shame, because the book’s themes would have enormously benefited from a serious and adult entryway into the fabric of our familiar our social and work lives. Hamid’s ideas on natural hate and fundamentalism often make a lot of sense – enough sense, in fact, for them to merit some consideration and a better literary venue. Whether the reluctant fundamentalist is Changez, AmErica or even the reader, and while it seems reasonable to assume neither party is adequately exempt from the folly and fanaticism of our contemporary world, it seems safe to say that Mohsin Hamid achieves here a significant commentary. That is reads more like a primer than a definite novel on the subject is its only significant flaw.
It takes a lot of guts to propose that hate may be just a matter of instinct, and a lot of finesse to pull the discussion out of the tired and beaten philosophical debates on human nature. While there is certainly more to this short book, the educated reader who encounters it has to contend with the uncomfortable notion that no approach to this complex issue can achieve complete plausibility in the artificial realm of human logic. After all, there are a thousand reasons to love as well as a thousand reasons to hate, and a society that preaches and frequently lauds the former for its irrational and abstract characteristics cannot seriously dwell under the hypocritical assumption that the same reasoning is not applicable to the latter.